The good, bad and ugly of doggie treadmills


Leave it to us humans to introduce dogs to the joys of working hard and getting nowhere.

The American Pet Products Association (APPA) reports that about 3 million dogs across the country were using treadmills in 2010.

Given widespread obesity in the species (I think we taught them that, too), it’s not an entirely bad thing for dogs to be getting workouts on treadmills.

But there is a monotony to it that strikes me as running counter to what dogs are all about. Show me the dog that prefers a treadmill to running outdoors — in nature, free to veer this way and that, to stop and sniff when the spirit moves him — and I’ll show you a dog that, quite possibly, has become too human.

On the other hand, if the treadmill is the only exercise a dog is going to get, I guess we’ll just have to accept that the times are changing.

According to the Associated Press, the latest APPA survey of pet owners marked the first time the treadmill question was included, based on reports that doggie treadmills were selling briskly. The survey found 3 million dogs made use of them, which is about one of every 25 dogs in the country.

The reasons for resorting to a treadmill are many, and often valid – when it’s too hot out, too cold out; when a pet’s human has become temporarily, or permanently, immobile; when an injured dog needs a controlled form of exercise.

While the AP article explored only the upside of dog treadmills, it strikes me that — like most technology — they carry a high probability of being misused.

Putting your dog on the treadmill could become the equivalent of putting your child in front of the TV set — a way to keep them occupied and quiet. All us folks who seem to think we’re too busy for a walk in the park could come to over rely on them.

The argument could be made, and maybe will: If you don’t have the time and energy to walk a dog, don’t get one — at least not one that requires a lot of exercise.

The AP article mentions one woman in Las Vegas whose rescued dog had dropped from 115 pounds to 80 using a treadmill. That impressed her so much that she bought her own dog treadmill, which is now used by all four of her dogs — too many, she said, to walk at one time.

“I want to make sure the rest of their lives are the healthiest we can make them. If the treadmill promotes a longer life, then it’s easy to do it each day … Whatever we can do now to help them lead a healthier, better life is worth it,” she said.

All that’s true, as long as its not the only activity the dog is getting. Frolicking in the grass and socializing with other dogs also makes for a healthier dog. So while I don’t want a doggie treadmill in my home, or, worse yet, a human one, it’s clear they do have their place.

Dog trainer April Suhr of Las Vegas believes shelters across the country could make good use of them. Getting out of their kennels and onto a treadmill a few times a week could keep shelter dogs from going “cage crazy” and make them healthier, happier and more adoptable, she says.

Suhr has a treadmill at home for her three pets and her foster dogs. Giving them the same amount of exercise by walking and running with them would take several hour and many miles, she noted.

Doggie treadmills, which are built smaller than human ones, come in a range of sizes and prices, starting at nearly $500.

DogPacer, maker of one of the newest and least expensive on the market at $499, has plans to start producing a less costly treadmill for toy dogs in September. Pennsylvania-based GoPet sells canine treadmills and a treadwheel, ranging from $475 to $1,225.

Interestingly, dogs being forced to run on treadmills was one of the first causes taken up when America’s animal welfare movement was finding its footing.

Until the late 1800s — and here’s where we get to the ugly part – dogs were bred and put to work at many a restaurant and inn as turnspit dogs. They were placed in wooden wheels, similar to that you’d see in a hamster’s cage, and encouraged to walk. The wheel powered a chain drive that rotated a spit above a fireplace, ensuring that the meat on the spit cooked evenly.

The short-legged dogs, bred small enough to fit in the wheel, would often be leashed in a way that made them choke if they stopped.  Often, a hot coal would be tossed into the wheel to speed a dog up.

When Henry Bergh established the ASPCA in the 1860s, one of his first campaigns was to end the practice.

That a device similar to one once used to enslave and abuse dogs is now being sold — for $1,000 and more — to pamper them and keep them healthy is ironic to say the least. Though it’s with kinder, gentler intentions, we seem in a way to be, after 150 years of stepping forward, back in the same place.

I think that says something; I’m just not sure what.

(Photo: A Belgian Malinois works out on a treadmill at  LA Dog Works in Los Angeles; by Grant Hindsley / Associated Press)

Comments

Comment from vida
Time August 21, 2012 at 6:22 pm

For people who through age or disability can’t get their dogs exercise I can see it. But walking/playing time is bonding time, it’s shared time. Treadmill time is mindless lonely time. I don’t think it says anything good and no treadmill will give the dog, or owner the joy of that leash dance or a game of fetch. If you don’t want to spend time with your dog don’t get one.

Comment from Pamela
Time August 21, 2012 at 9:16 pm

People often mistake exercise for stimulation. I can’t physically tire out my Golden Retriever on a walk. What exhausts her is the stimulation that comes from sniffing, greeting other people and dogs, seeing squirrels and cats, and the training we do. An engaged walk outdoors will always engage a dog’s brain more than time on a treadmill.

Of course, I don’t understand why humans use treadmills either. Yuck! Why not just go for a run outdoors?

Comment from alicia wolman
Time August 25, 2012 at 9:53 am

you are right they used treadmills in the older times – but now we are using them for a different purpose.
Dogs who would not normally get that kind of exercise can now benefit!
- you can always have the argument that people shouldn’t own dogs if they cant give them proper exercise – but people still do it. they will always do it – unless we have a laws + enforcement that forbid it. \
since that’s not going to happen – treadmills are a godsend.

there are WAY more benefits to using them than negativities.

“”"”Putting your dog on the treadmill could become the equivalent of putting your child in front of the TV set — a way to keep them occupied and quiet. All us folks who seem to think we’re too busy for a walk in the park could come to over rely on them.”"”"”

— this is not true because if we put kids in front of the tv, they do not burn any calories. putting your dog on the treadmill is not a substitute for fresh air – it’s a supplement and AID for exercise when other environmental factors are not available.

I totally support treadmills!!!
however, I usually use the free ones off craigslist for humans – no need for anything fancy

Comment from Patricia Kucik
Time October 29, 2012 at 5:42 pm

These are a great help for the elderly or people who live in a high rise apt or condo or the disabled just to name a few.

Comment from Lois Precourt
Time March 18, 2013 at 9:02 pm

I am in Wisconsin, have a small dog, and walking on the cold, icy, winter days is too dangerous for me. I bought a small sized dog treadmill – no sides to it, so she does not feel confined. Took about one minute for her to get the hang of it. I never leave her side when she is on, never put her on after she has eaten, keep the room cool, and monitor her body language. She runs to get on the treadmill, her tail is up, she appears excited and relaxed. She walks for 15 minutes at 2 MPH, well below what we do when we go outside. Properly used, I think it can have a positive benefit, but not to be replaced by outside activity when weather permits.

Write a comment