Reopening the door for a Boston terrier

powell1961Moe and Poochie.jpg

 

As irreplaceable as dogs are — and Charlie Powell considered his childhood dog, Poochie, just that — the best thing to do when you lose one is to fairly quickly get another.

Powell,  senior public-information officer for Washington State University’s College of Veterinary Medicine in Pullman, learned that lesson the hard way, letting 30 dogless years elapse after Poochie died.

In a haunting, inspiring and pretty darned wise essay in last week’s Seattle Times, Powell told the story of Poochie, the Boston terrier who was his first dog.

“My mother often said she thought I would pet his head bald with my right hand while sucking a bottle held in my left. She also said Poochie had no problem with that.”

After accompanying Powell through much of his childhood, the day came that Poochie, achy and elderly, had to be put down. Powell recalls the trip to the vet, and going with his father to bury Poochie near Lake Mead in Nevada.

Traumatic as that might have been for a 10-year-old, it got worse. When he and his father, on a fishing trip, later returned to the site where they’d laid Poochie to rest, they found the grave desecrated.

“There was trash around his grave where people had partied. There was a blackened fire ring where we buried him with the burned hinges and the hasp laying there. When I looked up, I saw his partially charred body hung by the neck from a limb with the wire we used to close the box…”

The impact of that, somewhat understandably, would last 30 years.

“For me, the memory of what happened was more like a featureless wall that one is unable to scale. I think I coped with this mainly by becoming ambivalent to dogs — all dogs.”

His family got other dogs, he writes, “but I was never close to any of them. I just never wanted to be that close to a dog again.” Even while working  at Washington State’s College of Veterinary Medicine, and for the Washington State Veterinary Medical Association, he had no desire — at least not that he was aware of – to have a dog of his own.

Then one day his wife went to a dog show, and — though he’d never mentioned Poochie to her — fell in love with Boston terriers, to the point she ordered one from a breeder, and asked her husband to pick up the dog, a brindle-colored male named ”Buster.”

“My mind raced. I fretted all week. How could I get another dog? What if his fate turned out to be worse than Poochie’s? Did my wife expect me to “replace” Poochie? Of course that was unfair to her; she knew nothing of Poochie. So I decided I needed to keep the wall up for the time being.”

We all know how good dogs are at knocking such walls down, and that’s what Buster did.

“Buster blossomed into a well-mannered young man that wormed his velvety head into my heart.

“Part of what I had avoided since Poochie died was eye contact with other dogs. But just try and avoid eye contact with a Boston terrier in your house, those two orbs that stick out on the corners of a cube-shaped head. It’s impossible.”

Buster2.JPG

Powell would go on to feature Buster regularly in vet school publications, and he once brought him along to a Washington State Veterinary Medical Association meeting, where “he sat in the conference room next to me wearing his WSU bow tie as if he were deliberating.”

As Powell notes Buster wasn’t Poochie — and it would be wrong to have expected him to be. When one dog dies, and you get another, the new one isn’t a replacement, and isn’t just a painkiller. He or she is unique — another chance to enjoy the magic of the species, another chance, for a dog lover, for love.

“Between Poochie and Buster was a long time to stay silent and deny myself the joy of another dog,” Powell wrote. “With Buster’s passing, I realized that I had shortchanged myself for a long time for no good reason. The very thing I thought I was protecting myself from — life with another dog — turned out to be the best thing for me.”

(Editor’s note: After the death of Buster, Powell adopted another Boston terrier, this one a blind and deaf 13-year-old rescue. Her name is CeCe.)

(Photos: Poochie and Powell in 1961, courtesy of Charlie Powell; Buster in a vet school post card, by Henry Moore Jr. / BCU/WSU)

Comments

Comment from KateH
Time November 12, 2012 at 8:11 pm

I always feel sad for people who, after their dog or cat (or other pet) passes on, say “I won’t get another.” To deny yourself the love of a friend, no matter what kind, is, to me, a type of masochism, and totally unhelpful going forward in life. Yes, sometimes your life changes and a pet would require more time/money/space than you can give, and those are far more understandable reasons for not having a pet, but hopefully, you wouldn’t deny yourself the happiness of liking, even searching out, other animals to interact with when you can.

Comment from vida
Time November 12, 2012 at 8:21 pm

I can’t imagine the pain of seeing a beloved pet’s resting place desecrated, his body desecrated. That would wreck me, I can understand his wanting to stay safe from that pain. But a dog will find his way into your heart one way or the other and it’s the best place for both of you to have him.

Comment from john
Time November 16, 2012 at 2:11 am

yes, each dog is an individual, unique in it’s own way, like a person. my boston terrier, sugar, will be eight this thanksgiving. her love has made a tremendous difference in my life. they are a great breed.

Comment from smoketoomuch
Time November 22, 2012 at 5:17 pm

After the death of my beloved Main Coon cat “Gypsy” (from a stroke followed by a cerebral hemorrhage) at only 13, I too took the path of no more pets. The depth of my sorrow at her loss, coupled with the lack of empathy and understanding from those around me left me with no other choice, or so I thought at the time. That was may years ago now, and though I still grieve the loss, and miss her greatly, serendipity brought a new animal into my life – our (now 6 year old) Pomeranian “Haley-Bear”. It’s wonderful to once again have the love and devotion of an animal, and though I know that she too will one day depart this life, I regret my earlier decision to live without the joy a companion animal in my life. Besides, there are too many cats and dogs in shelters waiting for their forever home. Pets make us complete, they have much to teach without uttering a single word, and all they ask for in return is care and attention. Never again will I be without a cat or a dog in my life.

Write a comment