OUR BEST FRIENDS

whs-logo

The Sergei Foundation

shelterpet_logo

The Animal Rescue Site

B-more Dog

aldflogo

Pinups for Pitbulls

philadoptables

TFPF_Logo

Mid Atlantic Pug Rescue

Our Pack, Inc.

Maine Coonhound Rescue

Saving Shelter Pets, Inc.

mabb

LD Logo Color

When is it OK to pick a dog up by the tail?

cross1

Amid the bashing she’s taking on the Internet for picking her dog up by the tail, there are those coming to the defense of Rebecca Cross, owner of Knopa, the Scottish terrier who won Best in Show at Crufts.

But the explanations those defenders offer, and their justifications for the practice — which has existed for years — are disingenuous, misleading and often a little arrogant.

The only time, in our opinion, that a dog should be picked up by his or her tail is … NEVER!

There may be those in the dog show community, and in the worlds of hunters and breeders, who say that view is naive — that certain breeds can handle it. Then again, they have never been picked up by their tails.

Let’s look at their arguments.

1. The tails of some dog breeds are meant to serve that function. They are born with sturdier tails to provide us humans with handles so we can pull them out when they go into holes. Baloney. Clearly, neither God nor evolution put tails on animals to serve as handles for humans. And if breeders have worked to give certain breeds stronger tails, with that in mind, then they had the wrong thing in mind, which is often the case. Their tinkering with dog breeds to make them cuter, lower maintenance or more useful to humans — all in the name of sales, of course — leads to no good, and to bogus arguments like this one.

2. You shouldn’t do it, but, being highly skilled professionals, it’s OK for us to lift certain small breeds by their tails. Balderdash! Running around in a circle with a dog, and brushing its hair, doesn’t make you a highly skilled professional. Showing a dog doesn’t require a PhD. You’re not a doctor, and if you were you’d know that, the tail being an extension of the spine, it should not be used to hold up even part of a dog’s weight.

3. When a dog is picked up that way, most of the pressure is on the front end of the dog, and the tail is simply used as a guide. Bullshit — pardon our language — but anyone with the slightest understanding of physics can see that, when a dog is picked up this way, the tail is carrying at least some of the dog’s weight. And when the front end is being supported by a hand on his or her throat, rather than his or her chest, that too is problematic.

4. If it hurt them, dogs would yelp and whine. Wrong again! That’s not true of real world dogs, or show dogs — maybe especially show dogs who have accepted the fact that the human showing them is going to do this, just as they have accepted the judges who insist on grasping their packages to check for “conformity.”

5. We’ve always done it that way.  We all know that is no defense at all; rather, it’s an excuse used by those who — even when someone is showing them a better way — stubbornly insist on living in the past. And if ever there was a vestige of the past, it’s purebred dog shows.

Those defending the practice offer plenty of what they, at least, see as justification, but little explanation of the reason for picking up a dog this way in the first place.

cross2That’s probably because it is such a silly and superficial reason: By using those two points of contact, they can avoid messing up the dog’s hair.

In that way, the tail lift symbolizes what, at the root, is wrong with dog shows.

And that’s the “appearance above all” mentality behind them.

Judging dogs on their looks — as called for by breed organizations and breed standards — causes suffering and is not in the best interest of the species.

Shows like Crufts and Westminster value “looks over the welfare and health of dogs which can lead to their early death, and that’s not acceptable if we’re really a nation of dog lovers,” RSPCA spokesperson Violet Owens told the BBC.

Although the dog owner’s comments didn’t sound too apologetic — she said she lifted her dog by the tail due to force of habit — Cross did apologize, according to UK Kennel Club Secretary Caroline Kisko.

And just for the record Kisko also said that — no matter what the breed — picking up a dog by its tail is a no-no, at least at Crufts:

“Those showing at Crufts receive clear written guidance on handling their dog, in order to ensure the dog’s welfare, and this guidance makes it clear that dogs should not be handled in this way,” she said.

Comments

Comment from kathryn
Time March 13, 2015 at 3:30 pm

Just for the record, it doesn’t follow that Crufts would bestow its Best in Show award on a dog whose owner was not following its guidelines on how to handle the dog. Does that compute in antone else’s hopper?

Comment from Anonymous
Time March 14, 2015 at 2:33 pm

Guidelines are only as humane as the sometimes misled humans who are making the rules. Maybe they need to revise their guidelines. Too bad we can’t ask the dogs if they like being picked up by their tail or stood upon or bounced on, etc. I’m fairly certain of how our pets would respond.

Pingback from Roundup #5 – The Best Dog Articles of the Week – Puppy Leaks
Time March 14, 2015 at 6:00 pm

[…] Should a Dog Ever Be Picked up by the Tail? The recent winner of Crufts has taken a public bashing after picking up her dog by his tail. Here’s a look into the controversy and some insight into what Crufts & the UK Kennel Club has to say about it. […]

Comment from reddawg
Time March 15, 2015 at 8:59 am

At least 100,000 say never. Will the outrage
prompt guideline visions?
100,000 sign petition for handler to be stripped of award after she was filmed picking up prized dog by the TAIL

Comment from reddawg
Time March 15, 2015 at 9:00 am

visions=REvisions

Comment from Barkocity – Cara
Time March 16, 2015 at 4:08 pm

As humans, we all make mistakes. But this literally only takes common sense to understand that it’s not right to pick up a dog by it’s tail! Rules are rules, it doesn’t mean we need to follow them if we feel like they’re wrong! Not all rules are RIGHT! Poor pooch 🙁

Pingback from We Trust Many of Our Readers Know This, But Do Your Kids? – Big Barker Blog
Time March 16, 2015 at 9:06 pm

[…] Read the full article here: When is it ok to pick a dog up by the tail? […]